Ghost Jobs: Unveiling the Phantom Workforce of Tomorrow

In the perplexing landscape of the modern job market, Ivan Fernandez, a writer hailing from L.A., found himself amid a frustrating search for employment roughly a year ago. "It's almost like swinging at a piñata blindfolded. It's like, what am I gonna hit, if anything?" he expressed. Today's employment report paints a picture of a slight rise in the unemployment rate to 4%. However, for individuals like Fernandez, the relentless cycle of applying for countless jobs without receiving any response has become wearisome, prompting questions about the authenticity of job listings.

This predicament isn't merely an annoyance for job seekers; it poses a significant challenge for entities like the Federal Reserve as they endeavor to gauge the extent of slack within the labor market and determine appropriate monetary policies. Revelio Labs, a firm specializing in jobs analytics, delved into what they term "ghost jobs" by scrutinizing the conversion rate of job postings into actual hires. Their analysis revealed a stark trend: since 2018, the number of hires has dwindled in comparison to the volume of job listings. Lisa Simon, the chief economist at Revelio Labs, characterized these findings as "astounding," highlighting that one in two job postings fails to culminate in a hire.

Another specter haunting job seekers is the phenomenon of ghosting, where employers initiate the interview process but fail to communicate the outcome to candidates. Revelio Labs observed a notable surge in the frequency of the term "ghosting" in online reviews on platforms like Indeed and Glassdoor. Understanding the prevalence of ghost jobs is imperative for policymakers to accurately assess the economic landscape. The Federal Reserve's current strategy of maintaining higher interest rates aims to curb inflation and prevent a downturn in the labor market. The ratio of job openings to unemployed individuals serves as a critical metric for assessing the health of the job market, making the existence of ghost postings a potential confounding factor.

Kim Riley, an economist at the Bureau of Labor Statistics, emphasizes the necessity for employers to actively recruit for their job openings. While the Bureau's survey program is familiar with the concept of ghost jobs, it lacks specific data on these phenomena. As for Fernandez, after a seven-month quest, he encountered a genuine job posting for a coordinator position at a youth counseling nonprofit. This opportunity proved to be tangible, requiring no supernatural intervention for him to secure the position.

Introducing a series of insightful episodes:

Not too hot, not too cold: a 'Goldilocks' jobs report

Discover the nuances of the latest jobs report, exploring its significance in the broader economic landscape. Is it just right, like Goldilocks' porridge, or are there underlying challenges?

The Beigie Awards: From Ghosting to Coasting

Delve into the intriguing world of employment dynamics as we unveil the winners of the Beigie Awards, recognizing exceptional achievements and notable trends, from the perplexing phenomenon of ghosting to the effortless journey of coasting through career transitions.

For sponsor-free access to thought-provoking episodes of The Indicator from Planet Money, join Planet Money+ on Apple Podcasts or at

Immerse yourself in the captivating soundscapes crafted by Drop Electric.

Connect with us across social media platforms: TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, and subscribe to our Newsletter for exclusive updates and insights.

In conclusion, these episodes offer a comprehensive exploration of the intricacies within the contemporary job market, shedding light on both the challenges and opportunities that individuals and policymakers face. From dissecting the Goldilocks-esque balance of the latest jobs report to celebrating the winners of the Beigie Awards, each installment provides valuable insights into the ever-evolving landscape of employment dynamics. As we navigate the complexities of today's economy, let us continue to delve deeper, armed with knowledge and understanding, towards fostering a more resilient and inclusive workforce for the future.